A publisher emails an author with an offer: opt in to an AI licensing program and share the proceeds. The author searches for guidance and finds a number. The Authors Guild has said that a fair split for most AI licensing deals gives 75 to 85 percent to the author. The number is real, and it is useful. It is also a position statement, not a rule, and nothing in it binds a publisher, a contract, or a court. Whether the benchmark is negotiable depends on what bargaining power the author actually holds.
This article is informational and is not legal advice. Contract language varies, so have a licensed attorney or literary agent review any offer.
What the Guild Actually Said
The figure comes from the Guild’s December 12, 2024 statement, “AI Licensing for Authors: Who Owns the Rights and What’s a Fair Split?” It says a fair split for most deals will give 75 to 85 percent to the author, depending on the publisher’s role. Three qualifiers sit inside that sentence and the text around it.
The range depends on what the publisher does. The Guild says a publisher acting only as an agent should receive something like an agent’s fee. A publisher that does more work, such as assembling the licensed bundle or preparing text files and metadata, should be compensated for its costs and labor.
The author’s share should flow directly to the author. The Guild says it should not be applied against an advance.
The Guild criticized lower offers. It called out some academic presses for offering authors only 25 percent.
A separate Guild resource, “AI Licensing: What Authors Should Know,” narrows the recommendation for training-only licenses. It suggests 80/20 or 75/25, with the higher share going to the author, when the publisher is involved and provides the final text file. It adds that other splits are addressed by the contract. In other words, even the Guild’s own guidance changes with the use case.
Why It Is a Benchmark and Not a Rule
The Guild is an advocacy organization. Its numbers shape expectations, press coverage, and what agents ask for, but no publisher signs onto them and no statute sets them.
The gap between the benchmark and practice showed up quickly. In November 2024 HarperCollins offered a program under which each participating author would receive part of a $5,000 per-title fee, split 50-50 between author and publisher, for nonfiction books licensed to an unnamed AI company. The Guild’s account of the deal notes that the offer was opt-in, with HarperCollins requesting express permission from each author individually, and that payments would be made separately rather than applied against advances. It also reports guardrails, including output limits of 200 consecutive words and 5 percent of a book’s text. The Guild said the 50-50 division “gives far too much to the publisher.”
So one major publisher put a 50 percent number on the table while the author-side benchmark sat 25 to 35 points higher. Both facts are useful. The 75-85 benchmark did not stop the offer. For an individual author, the publisher’s number is an opening position, not a final one.
The Guild’s model contract clauses show a second layer. Per its AI model clauses, the suggested splits for training, character chat, fan fiction, and multi-book chat run 80 to 90 percent to the author, while uses such as retrieval-augmented generation, summaries, and “chat with the book” are suggested at 50/50. A single deal can therefore involve several different splits, depending on what the licensee does with the text.
Where an Author’s Bargaining Power Comes From
A benchmark has force only when the author can say no. The Guild’s position is that the author can, because AI training rights were not granted in standard publishing agreements.
The Guild says that it knows of no contract that includes AI training as a subsidiary right, that publishers must obtain separate permission before licensing AI rights, and that “AI rights remain with the author.” It also says some publishers have wrongly argued that “other digital” or “other electronic” rights language reaches AI training. In its view, trade contracts typically reserve to the author every right not expressly granted, so even a broad reproduction clause does not authorize licensing a book to an AI developer.
Treat that as the Guild’s reading rather than settled law. We did not find a court decision that resolves how an “other electronic rights” grant applies to AI training, and your contract’s own wording controls. The Guild also acknowledges that some academic contracts transfer full copyright to the publisher, in which case an author may hold no rights unless the contract says otherwise. Bargaining power differs sharply between a trade contract with a rights reservation and an academic assignment of copyright.
For related background on what a publisher can and cannot do with a backlist title, see our look at publishers licensing backlist titles to AI companies.
What to Check Before You Accept a Split
When an offer arrives, the percentage is only one line. These questions matter as much.
What is the publisher actually doing?
If the publisher is passing along a licensee’s request and collecting payment, the Guild’s logic points toward an agent-level fee. If it is preparing files, cleaning metadata, or packaging many titles, a larger share can be justified, but the work should be specific and the costs should be explained.
What exactly is being licensed?
Training, retrieval, summaries, character chat, and fan-fiction style uses are different products. A split quoted for one is not a split for the rest. Ask which uses the license covers and whether the split is stated per use.
Is the money kept away from your advance?
The Guild says payments should not be applied against an advance. The HarperCollins program, as the Guild described it, paid separately. If an offer folds AI income into your royalty account, you may never see it.
Who approves the licensee and the term?
The Guild’s optional model language asks for author approval of deals, with notice of 15 business days, and for pass-through of licensing income within 30 days. Those are the Guild’s suggested contract terms, not industry standards. They still give you a concrete list to bring to a negotiation.
Is the license exclusive, and for how long?
A non-exclusive license leaves you free to license the same text elsewhere. An open-ended or exclusive grant can lock the title up for years, which matters if the market for AI licensing is still being priced.
What are the guardrails?
Output limits, a promise not to scrape pirate sites, and restrictions on competing uses all appear in the HarperCollins terms as the Guild reported them. Look for equivalent protections in any offer you receive.
So Is the Benchmark Negotiable?
The benchmark is a negotiating position, and it is negotiable in the sense that every number is. It cannot be enforced. What gives it weight is the underlying claim that the right to license AI use belongs to the author unless the contract says otherwise. Where that holds, an author or agent can decline, counter at 75 to 85 percent, or ask the publisher to justify a lower share with specific costs.
Where the contract assigns copyright outright, the author has less to bargain with and the benchmark is mostly a measure of fairness rather than a lever. Before replying to any offer, find your contract’s grant of rights, its reservation clause, and its definition of electronic rights, and get a professional to read them with the AI offer beside them.

